Monday, February 15, 2010

Prompt 2

Prompt 2: Choose a character in a novel or play of your choice (from the AP List!) and write about the conflict(s) that arise since they are in conflict with the society they are from. This may be socially, religiously, and/or morally. Dig deep! You should also address whether your character comes to a good/bad fate due to this conflict(s).

Heathcliff, the central character of Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights, transformed himself from the status of an impoverished orphan to that of a wealthy gentleman in a society that centered around social standing. Taken off of the streets of industrialized Liverpool, Heathcliff is abruptly transplanted into a class conscious village in the English countryside. With the exception of a select few, Heathcliff is immediately disliked by his new peers and shunned for his ill mannered ways. In response to losing his true love to a high society gentleman, Heathcliff embarks on an elaborate plan in which he seeks to take revenge upon those who had alienated him as a child.

The orphaned Heathcliff is adopted into Wuthering Heights, the home of the Earnshaws’. Heathcliff is adored by Mr. Earnshaw but remains tormented Mr. Earnshaw’s son, Hindley, who takes control of Wuthering Heights after his father dies. Although Heathcliff is often ostracized as a child for being a “gypsy,” he easily earns the admiration of Mr. Earnshaw’s daughter, Catherine. Heathcliff and Catherine grow to be great companions and eventually lovers. However, once Catherine matures, her desire for social advancement overpowers her feelings for Heathcliff and she begins a relationship with Edgar from the Thrushcross Grange manor. Catherine recognizes that her love for Heathcliff is greater than her love for Edgar, but her want of stability and a life of affluence pushes her to marry Edgar whose family is very respected throughout the village. Devastated by Catherine’s betrayal and tired of Hindley’s terrible treatment, Heathcliff leaves Wuthering Heights for years and vows to take revenge upon Hindley and Edgar.

Heathcliff returns to the English countryside after amassing a fortune. Despite being alienated as a child for his poor breeding, Heathcliff is now more respected for the wealth that he has gained. The first act in his plan of revenge is to obtain the property of Wuthering Heights from Hindley, who had always made his life miserable as a child. Heathcliff manipulatively gets Hindley to borrow money from him; as Hindley is unable to pay off his debts, Heathcliff slyly assumes control over Wuthering Heights.

Eager to get revenge upon Edgar for marrying Catherine, Heathcliff works to gain the property of Thrushcross Grange. In the hopes of putting himself in a position to inherit Thrusscross Grange and infuriating Edgar, Heathcliff convinces Edgar’s sister, Isabella, to marry him. After their wedding, Heathcliff treats Isabella horribly and ignores their son, Linton. At around the same time, Edgar and Catherine have a daughter, Cathy. Years pass in which Catherine and Isabella die and their children Linton and Cathy grow up. During this time, Edgar has become sickly as has Linton. Heathcliff remains resentful towards Edgar and still wants the property of Thrushcross Grange. In a desperate attempt to gain the property, he holds Cathy captive in Wuthering Heights and does not allow her to leave until she and Linton get married. Linton and Edgar die and Heathcliff, now having both properties of Wuthering Heights and Thrushcross Grange has fulfilled his quest of revenge.

Heathcliff’s actions throughout the novel Wuthering Heights all center around his quest of revenge against those who had treated him wrongly because of his low birth. In this society, a man is defined by his breeding, wealth and property. Heathcliff’s actions are driven by a need to compensate for what he was born lacking. Although Heathcliff is successful in gaining wealth and property, his vengeful actions do not make up for the loss of his true love, Catherine, and he dies a man obsessed and haunted by the memory of her.

(written in about 50 minutes)

7 comments:

  1. I both loved and hated that book. I loved it because it's a lover's book about love, but also hated it because something as stupid as society got between two lovers in love and that made me sad. :(

    I liked your review, but I think you could explore more about how Heathcliff tried to beat society by playing by its own rules. It defeated him by taking Catherine away, but he did everything by "the book" and maneuvered around until he got what he wanted--but his love could not overpower those horrible societal rules. I like the fact that you brought up Catherine and how she chose society over Heathcliff--that was a good example of how he was totally losing all the time. (I really hated Catherine for that; if she was so intelligent she would have picked happiness over wealth but nooooooo.)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Lexi,

    I've never read Wuthering Heights, but from reading your blog, I think I'm kind of interested in it now :) I liked your essay and how you explained why the character was in conflict with his society, but how his revenge ultimately led to his corruption. At times, I felt that it was kind of straying away from the topic and turning into a plot summary, though...but it all came together for me in the end with your concluding paragraph.

    Overall, you did great! :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey Lexi,

    I haven't read the book, but it sounds pretty intense. I liked your essay, because I really got what was happening in the story, even though I've never read it. I really understood the characters and the motivations behind Heathcliff as well, and how society pushed him into becoming what he was. It's a really good example of how sociey's expectations affected how the book played out. Sometimes I think you did go a little bit off the prompt of the society conflict, and I think that for some paragraphs, if you could have specified the events happening in the book with how it interacted with the theme of society, it would have been perfect. The ending was really good, though, and I really enjoyed reading your essay.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lexi,

    I liked that your essay was very detailed and it was well-written! You had good flow and organization.

    I think it strayed off answering the prompt and became more of summarizing the book (I did the same thing so I've been recognizing this kind of thing in other essays, haha..) but it was still very, very good.

    I really enjoyed reading it! And normally I hate reading long ones but I read this entire thing and I liked it :].

    ReplyDelete
  5. Oh my god I was gonna do Wuthering Heights but I decided not to because I had issues thinking of what to write! haha.
    Well I thought that for a plot summary of the book this would be really good because it had all the important details, however it did stray from the prompt so I wasn't sure what you were saying about the conflict too much..?
    I think maybe the conflict would have been an internal conflict since he couldn't solve his past feelings without seeking revenge? I'm not sure :p that's why I didn't do Wuthering Heights.
    But really good job on summarizing the plot! I'm sorry if I sound mean, I don't mean to!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Lexi, I have this book! But I didn't read it yet. Your response is extremely clear and well-written. I agree with Kell & Ari about summarizing the book, but I do think that you did a good job in going back to the prompt. Good Job! (:

    ReplyDelete
  7. Comment from Noelle (her computer was acting up, so she asked me to post her comments through my account.)
    ____________________________________________
    First off, woot! for using Weathering Height =D I must say, you did a good job of clealry identifying everyone, especially when there are some names that are duplacates. Beautifully written. I really liked how you not only explain the conflict at hand, but described how this conflict affect Heathcliff and how his actions caused more conflict. Complex, but realitively easy to follow. Your standpoint did get a little lost in the summary of the book, but I felt you did a good job of tying it all together in the final paragraph. Good job =]

    ReplyDelete